| Wabash leads all-time series, 54-53-9 DePauw leads Monon Bell series 37-35-6 (Bell was introduced in 1932) |
|||
|---|---|---|---|
| Year | Winner | Score | Site |
| 11/22/1890 | DePauw | 34-5 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/21/1891 | DePauw | 1-0(For) | Greencastle |
| 11/5/1892 | DePauw | 42-4 | Greencastle |
| 11/11/1893 | DePauw | 48-34 | Crawfordsville |
| 10/20/1894 | Wabash | 16-4 | Greencastle |
| 10/19/1895 | Wabash | 6-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 10/31/1896 | DePauw | 20-0 | Greencastle |
| 10/6/1900 | Wabash | 6-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/12/1900 | DePauw | 26-11 | Greencastle |
| 11/11/1901 | DePauw | 31-2 | Greencastle |
| 11/18/1901 | DePauw | 35-5 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/21/1903 | Wabash | 10-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/25/1905 | Wabash | 52-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/17/1906 | Wabash | 7-0 | Greencastle |
| 11/4/1907 | Wabash | 11-4 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/20/1908 | Wabash | 12-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 10/9/1909 | Tie | 0-0 | Greencastle |
| 10/13/1911 | Tie | 0-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 10/12/1912 | Wabash | 62-0 | Greencastle |
| 10/20/1913 | DePauw | 7-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/16/1914 | DePauw | 3-0 | Greencastle |
| 11/20/1915 | Wabash | 34-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/11/1916 | Wabash | 26-13 | Indianapolis |
| 11/10/1917 | DePauw | 7-0 | Indianapolis |
| 11/23/1918 | DePauw | 28-6 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/8/1919 | Tie | 0-0 | Indianapolis |
| 11/20/1920 | DePauw | 3-0 | Indianapolis |
| 11/19/1921 | Wabash | 22-0 | Indianapolis |
| 11/25/1922 | Wabash | 30-0 | Indianapolis |
| 11/24/1923 | Wabash | 17-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/22/1924 | Wabash | 21-0 | Greencastle |
| 11/21/1925 | Wabash | 22-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/20/1926 | Wabash | 6-0 | Greencastle |
| 11/19/1927 | Wabash | 13-7 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/24/1928 | DePauw | 20-12 | Greencastle |
| 11/23/1929 | Wabash | 8-7 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/22/1930 | DePauw | 7-6 | Greencastle |
| 11/21/1931 | DePauw | 13-7 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/19/1932 | Tie | 0-0 | Greencastle |
| 11/18/1933 | DePauw | 14-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/17/1934 | Wabash | 7-6 | Greencastle |
| 11/16/1935 | Tie | 0-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/14/1936 | Wabash | 19-0 | Greencastle |
| 11/13/1937 | DePauw | 32-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/12/1938 | DePauw | 7-0 | Greencastle |
| 11/18/1939 | DePauw | 7-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/16/1940 | Wabash | 17-13 | Greencastle |
| 11/15/1941 | Wabash | 27-19 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/14/1942 | DePauw | 6-3 | Greencastle |
| 10/16/1943 | DePauw | 33-0 | Greencastle |
| 10/21/1944 | Wabash | 14-7 | Crawfordsville |
| 9/22/1945 | DePauw | 13-7 | Greencastle |
| 11/16/1946 | Wabash | 26-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/15/1947 | Wabash | 27-7 | Greencastle |
| 11/13/1948 | DePauw | 8-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/12/1949 | Wabash | 25-21 | Greencastle |
| 11/18/1950 | Wabash | 34-20 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/17/1951 | Wabash | 41-12 | Greencastle |
| 11/15/1952 | Wabash | 47-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/14/1953 | Wabash | 41-0 | Greencastle |
| 11/13/1954 | Wabash | 28-0 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/12/1955 | DePauw | 23-20 | Greencastle |
| 11/17/1956 | Tie | 7-7 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/16/1957 | DePauw | 37-6 | Greencastle |
| 11/15/1958 | DePauw | 24-8 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/14/1959 | Tie | 6-6 | Greencastle |
| 11/12/1960 | DePauw | 14-13 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/18/1961 | DePauw | 20-7 | Greencastle |
| 11/17/1962 | DePauw | 13-10 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/16/1963 | DePauw | 17-0 | Greencastle |
| 11/14/1964 | DePauw | 22-21 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/13/1965 | Wabash | 16-6 | Greencastle |
| 11/12/1966 | DePauw | 9-7 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/11/1967 | Wabash | 7-0 | Greencastle |
| 11/16/1968 | DePauw | 18-7 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/15/1969 | DePauw | 17-7 | Greencastle |
| 11/7/1970 | DePauw | 14-13 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/13/1971 | Wabash | 16-7 | Greencastle |
| 11/11/1972 | Wabash | 20-14 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/10/1973 | DePauw | 28-21 | Greencastle |
| 11/16/1974 | DePauw | 15-12 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/15/1975 | DePauw | 14-8 | Greencastle |
| 11/13/1976 | Wabash | 14-7 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/12/1977 | Wabash | 30-6 | Greencastle |
| 11/11/1978 | Wabash | 11-3 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/10/1979 | Wabash | 16-13 | Greencastle |
| 11/8/1980 | Tie | 22-22 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/14/1981 | DePauw | 21-14 | Greencastle |
| 11/13/1982 | Wabash | 31-6 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/12/1983 | DePauw | 16-10 | Greencastle |
| 11/10/1984 | Wabash | 41-26 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/9/1985 | Wabash | 28-8 | Greencastle |
| 11/8/1986 | Wabash | 24-23 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/14/1987 | DePauw | 33-11 | Greencastle |
| 11/12/1988 | DePauw | 24-14 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/11/1989 | DePauw | 41-14 | Greencastle |
| 11/10/1990 | DePauw | 20-13 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/16/1991 | Wabash | 23-18 | Greencastle |
| 11/14/1992 | Tie | 17-17 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/13/1993 | Wabash | 40-26 | Greencastle |
| 11/12/1994 | Wabash | 28-24 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/11/1995 | Wabash | 7-2 | Greencastle |
| 11/16/1996 | DePauw | 31-13 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/15/1997 | DePauw | 14-7 | Greencastle |
| 11/14/1998 | DePauw | 42-7 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/13/1999 | DePauw | 21-7 | Greencastle |
| 11/11/2000 | DePauw | 27-17 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/10/2001 | Wabash | 27-21 | Greencastle |
| 11/16/2002 | Wabash | 35-7 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/15/2003 | Wabash | 37-20 | Greencastle |
| 11/13/2004 | DePauw | 14-7 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/12/2005 | Wabash | 17-14 | Greencastle |
| 11/11/2006 | Wabash | 23-20 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/10/2007 | DePauw | 24-21 | Greencastle |
| 11/15/2008 | DePauw | 36-14 | Crawfordsville |
| 11/14/2009 | Wabash | 32-19 | Greencastle |