| Points | |||
| 1694 | Brett Crist | 1987-91 | |
| 1675 | Brett Hecko | 1988-92 | |
| 1632 | Jeff Bibbs | 1976-80 | |
| 1546 | Joe Nixon | 1998-02 | |
| 1533 | Joe Ringger | 1999-03 | |
| 1415 | Stephen Schott | 2004-08 | |
| 1415 | Bob Schrier | 1953-57 | |
| 1404 | Ryan Hooker | 1993-97 | |
| 1370 | Dave Hathaway | 1980-84 | |
| 1360 | Gary Pittenger | 1970-73 | |
| 1307 | Tom McCormick | 1966-69 | |
| 1276 | Mike Howland | 1998-02 | |
| 1271 | Mike Connor | 1984-88 | |
| 1263 | Alex Stewart | 2002-06 | |
| 1231 | Jeff Hallgren | 1974-78 | |
| 1203 | David Galle | 1983-87 | |
| 1144 | Morgan Everson | 1963-66 | |
| 1134 | Dale Anderson | 1959-62 | |
| 1118 | Jeremy Bettis | 1999-03 | |
| 1090 | Herb Spier | 1959-62 | |
| 1027 | Mike Luegers | 1974-78 | |
| 1004 | John Bunnell | 1954-58 | |
| 979 | Mike Moore | 2005- | |
| 979 | Phil Wendel | 1982-86 | |
| 954 | Troy Greenlee | 1987-91 | |
| Scoring average (min. 50 games) | |||
| 19.2 | Dale Anderson | 1959-62 | |
| 18.9 | Tom McCormick | 1966-69 | |
| 18.6 | Bob Schrier | 1953-57 | |
| 18.1 | Gary Pittenger | 1970-73 | |
| 17.6 | Morgan Everson | 1963-66 | |
| 16.3 | Jeff Bibbs | 1976-80 | |
| 15.8 | Herb Spier | 1959-62 | |
| 15.6 | Joe Nixon | 1998-02 | |
| 15.5 | Brett Crist | 1987-91 | |
| 15.4 | Jeff Hallgren | 1974-78 | |
| 15.2 | Brett Hecko | 1988-92 | |
| 15.2 | Joe Ringger | 1999-03 | |
| 13.9 | Ryan Hooker | 1993-97 | |
| 13.8 | Tom McGurk | 1965-68 | |
| 13.5 | Jim Jackson | 1966-69 | |
| 13.2 | Stephen Schott | 2004-08 | |
| 13.0 | Dave Hathaway | 1980-84 | |
| 13. | Jack Hogan | 1964-67 | |
| 12.8 | Zach Phelps | 1991-94 | |
| 12.7 | Gene Loercher | 1951-54 | |
| Field goals made | |||
| 683 | Jeff Bibbs | 1976-80 | |
| 655 | Brett Hecko | 1988-92 | |
| 600 | Joe Ringger | 1999-03 | |
| 594 | Brett Crist | 1987-91 | |
| 561 | Dave Hathaway | 1980-84 | |
| 555 | Joe Nixon | 1998-02 | |
| 542 | Jeff Hallgren | 1974-78 | |
| 533 | Tom McCormick | 1966-69 | |
| 524 | Bob Schrier | 1953-57 | |
| 521 | Gary Pittenger | 1970-73 | |
| 516 | Stephen Schott | 1984-88 | |
| 509 | Mike Connor | 1984-88 | |
| 485 | David Galle | 1983-87 | |
| 453 | Dale Anderson | 1959-62 | |
| 450 | Ryan Hooker | 1993-97 | |
| 450 | Herb Spier | 1959-62 | |
| 440 | Alex Stewart | 2002-06 | |
| 420 | Mike Luegers | 1974-78 | |
| 419 | Jeremy Bettis | 1999-03 | |
| 410 | Morgan Everson | 1963-66 | |
| Field goals attempted | |||
| 1421 | Jeff Bibbs | 1976-80 | |
| 1327 | Bob Schrier | 1953-57 | |
| 1226 | Brett Crist | 1987-91 | |
| 1167 | Jeff Hallgren | 1974-78 | |
| 1153 | Herb Spier | 1959-62 | |
| 1112 | Brett Hecko | 1988-92 | |
| 1107 | Joe Nixon | 1998-02 | |
| 1101 | Tom McCormick | 1966-69 | |
| 1095 | Dave Hathaway | 1980-84 | |
| 1080 | Gary Pittenger | 1970-73 | |
| 1068 | Joe Ringger | 1999-03 | |
| 1033 | John Bunnell | 1954-58 | |
| 993 | Dale Anderson | 1959-62 | |
| 988 | Alex Stewart | 2002-06 | |
| 979 | Stephen Schott | 2004-08 | |
| 950 | Morgan Everson | 1963-66 | |
| 949 | Ryan Hooker | 1993-97 | |
| 912 | Bill Caskey | 1974-78 | |
| 900 | Mike Howland | 1998-02 | |
| 892 | Mike Connor | 1984-88 | |
| Field goal percentage (min. 250 made) | |||
| .589 | Brett Hecko | 1988-92 | 655/1112 |
| .587 | Craig McAtee | 1981-85 | 276/470 |
| .581 | Mike Luegers | 1974-78 | 420/723 |
| .571 | Mike Connor | 1984-88 | 509/892 |
| .571 | David Galle | 1983-87 | 485/850 |
| .568 | Jim Sandgren | 1984-88 | 254/447 |
| .562 | Joe Ringger | 1999-03 | 600/1068 |
| .546 | Austin Brown | 2003-07 | 335/614 |
| .545 | Joe Vanderkolk | 1982-86 | 269/494 |
| .527 | Stephen Schott | 2004-08 | 516/979 |
| .525 | Phil Wendel | 1982-86 | 376/716 |
| .524 | Jeremy Bettis | 1999-03 | 419/800 |
| .519 | Stan Bahler | 1963-66 | 334/644 |
| .517 | Tim Vieke | 1982-86 | 302/584 |
| .512 | Dave Hathaway | 1980-84 | 561/1095 |
| .511 | Joe Dixon | 1979-83 | 337/660 |
| .506 | Scott Lewis | 1983-87 | 281/555 |
| .501 | Joe Nixon | 1998-02 | 555/1107 |
| .497 | Tom McGurk | 1965-68 | 345/694 |
| .495 | Zach Phelps | 1991-94 | 255/515 |
| 3-point field goals made | |||
| 240 | Alex Stewart | 2002-06 | |
| 232 | Troy Greenlee | 1987-91 | |
| 208 | Reid Sakel | 2003-06 | |
| 184 | Joe Nixon | 1998-02 | |
| 168 | Mike Moore | 2005- | |
| 136 | Ryan Hooker | 1993-97 | |
| 135 | Todd Seifferlein | 1989-93 | |
| 125 | Bob Steiner | 1997-01 | |
| 123 | Mike Howland | 1998-02 | |
| 106 | Ryan Werntz | 2004-08 | |
| 102 | Craig Stewart | 1994-98 | |
| 99 | Ryan Miller | 1993-97 | |
| 96 | Zach Phelps | 1991-94 | |
| 95 | Jason Kreag | 1993-97 | |
| 93 | Brian Oilar | 2004-08 | |
| 92 | Brett Crist | 1987-91 | |
| 78 | Mark Burgher | 1989-93 | |
| 77 | Joey Hanger | 2001-05 | |
| 74 | Jon Owens | 2000-04 | |
| 64 | Brad Stevens | 1995-99 | |
| 64 | Brady Harvey | 1991-94 | |
| 3-point field goals attempted | |||
| 573 | Alex Stewart | 2002-06 | |
| 527 | Reid Sakel | 2003-07 | |
| 473 | Troy Greenlee | 1987-91 | |
| 438 | Joe Nixon | 1998-02 | |
| 423 | Mike Moore | 2005-08 | |
| 334 | Ryan Hooker | 1993-97 | |
| 298 | Mike Howland | 1998-02 | |
| 294 | Todd Seifferlein | 1989-93 | |
| 283 | Ryan Werntz | 2004-08 | |
| 279 | Bob Steiner | 1997-01 | |
| 277 | Ryan Miller | 1993-97 | |
| 269 | Craig Stewart | 1994-98 | |
| 237 | Brett Crist | 1987-91 | |
| 230 | Brian Oilar | 2004-08 | |
| 215 | Jason Kreag | 1993-97 | |
| 213 | Zach Phelps | 1991-94 | |
| 203 | Brad Stevens | 1995-99 | |
| 202 | Jon Owens | 2000-04 | |
| 199 | Joey Hanger | 2001-05 | |
| 181 | Mark Burgher | 1989-93 | |
| 3-point field goal % (minimun 50 made; no active players) | |||
| .490 | Troy Greenlee | 1987-91 | 232/473 |
| .463 | Randy Biederstedt | 1984-88 | 57/123 |
| .459 | Todd Seifferlein | 1989-93 | 135/294 |
| .451 | Zach Phelps | 1991-94 | 96/213 |
| .448 | Bob Steiner | 1997-01 | 125/279 |
| .442 | Jason Kreag | 1993-97 | 95/215 |
| .431 | Mark Burgher | 1989-93 | 78/181 |
| .420 | Joe Nixon | 1998-02 | 184/438 |
| .419 | Alex Stewart | 2002-06 | 240/573 |
| .413 | Mike Howland | 1998-02 | 123/298 |
| .407 | Ryan Hooker | 1993-97 | 136/334 |
| .404 | Brian Oilar | 2004-08 | 93/230 |
| .395 | Reid Sakel | 2003-07 | 208/527 |
| .388 | Brett Crist | 1987-91 | 92/237 |
| .387 | Joey Hanger | 2001-05 | 77/199 |
| .379 | Craig Stewart | 1994-98 | 102/269 |
| .375 | Ryan Werntz | 2004-08 | 106/283 |
| .366 | Jon Owens | 2000-04 | 74/202 |
| .3618 | Jeremy Bettis | 1999-03 | 55/152 |
| .3616 | Brady Harvey | 1991-94 | 64/177 |
| Free throws made | |||
| 414 | Brett Crist | 1987-91 | |
| 373 | Stephen Schott | 2004-08 | |
| 368 | Ryan Hooker | 1993-97 | |
| 367 | Bob Schrier | 1953-57 | |
| 364 | Brett Hecko | 1988-92 | |
| 357 | Mike Howland | 1998-02 | |
| 324 | Morgan Everson | 1963-66 | |
| 318 | Gary Pittenger | 1970-73 | |
| 315 | Joe Ringger | 1999-03 | |
| 266 | Jeff Bibbs | 1976-80 | |
| 263 | Tom McGurk | 1965-68 | |
| 253 | Mike Connor | 1984-88 | |
| 252 | Joe Nixon | 1998-02 | |
| 249 | Kent Guild | 1950-53 | |
| 248 | Dave Hathaway | 1980-84 | |
| 241 | Tom McCormick | 1966-69 | |
| 240 | Todd Seifferlein | 1989-93 | |
| 239 | Kirk Kitzinger | 1976-80 | |
| 233 | David Galle | 1983-87 | |
| 228 | Dale Anderson | 1959-62 | |
| Free throws attempted | |||
| 614 | Joe Ringger | 1999-03 | |
| 551 | Brett Crist | 1987-91 | |
| 518 | Bob Schrier | 1953-57 | |
| 517 | Brett Hecko | 1988-92 | |
| 508 | Stephen Schott | 2004-08 | |
| 497 | Ryan Hooker | 1993-97 | |
| 466 | Mike Howland | 1998-02 | |
| 451 | Gary Pittenger | 1970-73 | |
| 413 | Morgan Everson | 1963-66 | |
| 369 | Dale Anderson | 1959-62 | |
| 359 | Kirk Kitzinger | 1976-80 | |
| 352 | Kent Guild | 1950-53 | |
| 351 | Mike Connor | 1984-88 | |
| 346 | Jeff Bibbs | 1976-80 | |
| 345 | Mike Luegers | 1974-78 | |
| 343 | Tom McGurk | 1965-68 | |
| 340 | David Galle | 1983-87 | |
| 316 | Bing Davis | 1956-59 | |
| 314 | Dale Barrett | 1967-70 | |
| 310 | Dave Hathaway | 1980-84 | |
| Free throw percentage (minimum 100 made) | |||
| .861 | Gregg Notestine | 1980-83 | 124/144 |
| .859 | Ted Rutan | 1981-83 | 128/149 |
| .832 | Joe Nixon | 1998-02 | 252/303 |
| .823 | John Chin | 1971-74 | 130/158 |
| .821 | Reid Sakel | 2003-07 | 179/218 |
| .819 | Todd Seifferlein | 1989-93 | 240/293 |
| .816 | Zach Phelps | 1991-94 | 199/244 |
| .812 | Jeremy Bettis | 1999-03 | 225/277 |
| .803 | Joe Dixon | 1979-83 | 118/147 |
| .800 | Dave Hathaway | 1980-84 | 248/310 |
| .790 | Tom McCormick | 1966-69 | 241/305 |
| .785 | Morgan Everson | 1963-66 | 324/413 |
| .782 | Brad Brownell | 1988-91 | 151/193 |
| .769 | Jeff Bibbs | 1976-80 | 266/346 |
| .768 | Neal Ogle | 1982-86 | 156/203 |
| .767 | Tom McGurk | 1965-68 | 263/343 |
| .766 | Mike Howland | 1998-02 | 357/466 |
| .763 | Jim Callane | 1962-64 | 129/169 |
| .761 | Stan Bahler | 1963-66 | 143/188 |
| .759 | Phil Wendel | 1982-86 | 227/299 |
| Rebounds | |||
| 893 | Brett Hecko | 1988-92 | |
| 845 | Herb Spier | 1959-62 | |
| 816 | Stephen Schott | 2004-08 | |
| 761 | Joe Ringger | 1999-03 | |
| 730 | Jim Jackson | 1966-69 | |
| 725 | Bill Caskey | 1974-78 | |
| 698 | Tom McGurk | 1965-98 | |
| 686 | Mike Luegers | 1974-78 | |
| 671 | Bob Schrier | 1953-57 | |
| 638 | Kyle Fort | 1971-74 | |
| 607 | Kirk Kitzinger | 1976-80 | |
| 594 | Jeremy Bettis | 1999-03 | |
| 565 | Morgan Everson | 1963-66 | |
| 555 | David Galle | 1983-87 | |
| 555 | Tom McCormick | 1966-69 | |
| 550 | Joe Nixon | 1998-02 | |
| 546 | Dave Hathaway | 1980-84 | |
| 535 | Larry Downs | 1967-70 | |
| 531 | Dwight Tallman | 1956-59 | |
| 526 | Tom Johnson | 1955-58 | |
| Rebounding average | |||
| 12.6 | Jim Jackson | 1966-69 | |
| 12.2 | Herb Spier | 1959-62 | |
| 10.1 | Tom McGurk | 1965-68 | |
| 9.1 | Larry Downs | 1967-70 | |
| 9.0 | Gene Loercher | 1951-54 | |
| 8.9 | Tom Johnson | 1955-58 | |
| 8.9 | Dwight Tallman | 1956-59 | |
| 8.8 | Bob Schrier | 1963-57 | |
| 8.7 | Morgan Everson | 1963-66 | |
| 8.6 | Kyle Fort | 1971-74 | |
| 8.6 | Sam Ulmer | 1954-57 | |
| 8.3 | Mike Luegers | 1974-78 | |
| 8.1 | Brett Hecko | 1988-92 | |
| 8.0 | Tom McCormick | 1966-69 | |
| 7.9 | Bill Caskey | 1974-78 | |
| 7.6 | Stephen Schott | 2004-08 | |
| 7.6 | Dale Anderson | 1959-62 | |
| 7.5 | Joe Ringger | 1999-03 | |
| 7.5 | Kent Guild | 1950-53 | |
| 7.3 | Kirk Kitzinger | 1976-80 | |
| Assists | |||
| 600 | Phil Wendel | 1982-86 | |
| 490 | Mike Howland | 1998-02 | |
| 459 | Mike Moore | 2005-08 | |
| 380 | Scott Lewis | 1983-87 | |
| 351 | Brett Crist | 1987-91 | |
| 341 | Ted Rutan | 1981-83 | |
| 332 | Brad Brownell | 1988-91 | |
| 260 | Jeff Bibbs | 1976-80 | |
| 241 | Eric Bruksch | 1989-93 | |
| 223 | Joey Hanger | 2001-05 | |
| 220 | Gregg Notestine | 1980-83 | |
| 210 | David Galle | 1983-87 | |
| 196 | Reid Sakel | 2003-07 | |
| 189 | Ryan Hooker | 1993-97 | |
| 179 | Jason Kreag | 1993-97 | |
| 171 | Neal Ogle | 1982-86 | |
| 168 | Dan Falotico | 1984-88 | |
| 167 | Dave Hathaway | 1980-84 | |
| 164 | Jon Owens | 2000-04 | |
| 162 | Brett Hecko | 1988-92 | |
| Blocked Shots | |||
| 88 | Jim Giesen | 1991-95 | |
| 78 | Jeremy Bettis | 1999-03 | |
| 61 | Craig McAtee | 1981-85 | |
| 56 | Matt Carpenter | 1992-94 | |
| 54 | Brian Oilar | 2004-08 | |
| 53 | Joe Ringger | 1999-03 | |
| 51 | Matt McDonald | 2003-07 | |
| 44 | Rick Brown | 1994-97 | |
| 44 | Brett Hecko | 1988-92 | |
| 42 | Dave Hathaway | 1980-84 | |
| 37 | Mike Connor | 1984-88 | |
| 36 | Craig Stewart | 194-98 | |
| 31 | David Gray | 2006- | |
| 30 | Jon Owens | 2000-04 | |
| 29 | Stephen Schott | 2004-08 | |
| 28 | Todd Capes | 2003-06 | |
| 28 | Troy Langston | 1977-81 | |
| 27 | Jim Sandgren | 1984-88 | |
| 27 | Dan Falotico | 1984-88 | |
| 26 | Matt McCollum | 1992-96 | |
| Steals | |||
| 172 | Phil Wendel | 1982-86 | |
| 166 | Scott Lewis | 1983-87 | |
| 141 | Jon Owens | 2000-04 | |
| 141 | Eric Bruksch | 1989-93 | |
| 126 | Ryan Hooker | 1993-97 | |
| 123 | Brett Crist | 1987-91 | |
| 122 | Brett Hecko | 1988-92 | |
| 119 | David Galle | 1983-87 | |
| 112 | Mike Connor | 1984-88 | |
| 110 | Alex Stewart | 2002-06 | |
| 107 | Mike Howland | 1998-02 | |
| 105 | Dave Gifford | 1997-01 | |
| 102 | Brad Brownell | 1988-91 | |
| 100 | Reid Sakel | 2003-07 | |
| 100 | Dan Falotico | 1984-88 | |
| 98 | Craig Stewart | 1994-98 | |
| 96 | Gregg Notestine | 1980-83 | |
| 93 | Ted Rutan | 1981-83 | |
| 92 | Mike Moore | 2005- | |
| 88 | Joe Ringger | 1999-03 | |